- Gluttony dies after being devoured by Pride, another Homunculus, in an ironic twist.
- In the 2003 FMA anime, Gluttony dies begging Pride to stop and calling Lust’s name.
- Gluttony’s death scene in Brotherhood shows his fearful realization of being eaten.
- The manga and Brotherhood present Gluttony’s end as just desserts for his sin.
- Gluttony’s naive nature makes his pathetic death surprisingly poignant.
How does Gluttony meet his demise in Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood?
The homunculus Gluttony comes to a gruesome end in Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood when he is devoured by Pride, another member of the homunculi group. This serves as an ironic death for the character, given Gluttony’s insatiable appetite and habit of eating anything and everything he can. His terrifying death scene provides a dramatic moment in the show while also giving Gluttony a comeuppance befitting his sin.
What is Gluttony’s role and personality in FMA?
Throughout Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, Gluttony is depicted as a largely mindless and naive character whose primary motivation is consuming whatever he can. As his name suggests, Gluttony represents the sin of gluttony or overindulgence.
Physically, Gluttony appears as an overweight, childish bald man who towers over most other characters. He frequently drools over the prospect of eating and becomes uncontrollably excited around food.
However, Gluttony is also subservient and attached to Lust, obeying her orders. This includes using his power to devour anything instantly to eliminate enemies or evidence on command.
Despite his intimidating size and power, Gluttony’s childlike nature makes him seem innocent, if unsettling. He rarely speaks more than a few words and has little sense of the plans of the other villains.
What events lead up to Gluttony’s death in the manga and Brotherhood?
In both the manga and Brotherhood series, Gluttony meets his end after Lust is killed by Colonel Mustang. With Lust gone, Gluttony becomes lonely and distraught, having lost his maternal figure and controller.
The homunculi then begin carrying out Father’s nationwide transmutation circle plot, needing massive bloodshed and tragedy to succeed. However, Gluttony’s depression leaves him unreliable.
When Pride arrives in Central City to oversee the plot’s completion, he berates Gluttony for his current uselessness. His loyalty to Father is non-existent compared to the other homunculi.
After an alchemic mishap merges Pride and Gluttony together briefly, Pride decides that Gluttony has outlived his purpose. He invokes his shadows into Gluttony’s false Gate of Truth and ruthlessly devours him from the inside out.
How does Gluttony die in the 2003 FMA anime by comparison?
The 2003 anime adaptation of Fullmetal Alchemist handles Gluttony’s death quite differently, though the end result is the same. In this version, Gluttony is killed off for good during the confrontation under Lab 5 when he battles Edward Elric and Colonel Roy Mustang.
When Pride appears during this fight, Gluttony rushes to attack him, recognizing Pride as not being the same Selim he knows. But Pride immobilizes him using his shadows and slices Gluttony into pieces using his sword.
Even while dismembered and dying, Gluttony continues begging Pride to stop while crying out for Lust repeatedly. This highlights his simple-mindedness and devotion to Lust even in death. Gluttony makes no further appearances in the 2003 continuity after this battle.
What is the significance of Gluttony’s death by Pride in Brotherhood?
Gluttony’s excruciating death by being eaten alive serves both narrative and thematic purposes in Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood.
Most plainly, it eliminates an unstable asset for the homunculi while motivating Father to create a new Gluttony. This propels the overarching plot forward.
But more importantly, it completes Gluttony’s arc as the embodiment of his namesake sin in a twisted yet poetic way. After a life of endlessly indulging his hunger by devouring others, Gluttony ends up being eaten himself. As the old adage goes: “live by the sword, die by the sword.”
Having the equally monstrous Pride execute Gluttony also cements Pride’s superiority in power and ruthlessness over the other homunculi. Where Gluttony is a slave to his desires, Pride is fully in control and loyal only to Father above all else.
What is shown during Gluttony’s death scene in Brotherhood?
The visual depiction of Gluttony’s demise is brief but impactful. At first, he fails to understand what is happening to him as Pride’s black shadows invade his mouth and eyes.
But when Pride’s shadowy teeth begin tearing into him from within, Gluttony realizes his impending death and futilely attempts to push back. His childlike cries while being consumed set in stark relief Gluttony’s general innocence despite his villainy.
The added irony lies in the fact that it is Gluttony’s own false Gate of Truth that gives Pride access to devour him. The source of his power becomes his undoing.
Soon Gluttony’s desperate wails go silent, signalling his complete destruction. Only his Philosopher’s Stone is left behind – a grim end to the homunculus embodiment of endless hunger.
Why does Gluttony’s death elicit some sympathy despite his evil?
While played for horror, Gluttony’s gruesome death nonetheless gains a twinge of poignancy due to his childlike nature and attachment to Lust. Despite committing many monstrous acts, Gluttony has a innocence that makes his pathetic end surprisingly sad.
He lacks real understanding or care for Father’s master plans and the homunculi’s larger goals. With Lust gone, he is merely a broken, simple-minded creature at the end.
When Pride kills him, Gluttony could be seen as an undeserving victim clinging to life – bringing shades of humanity to the inhuman homunculus. While played for irony, his desperate cries as he realizes his own mortality evoke some empathy.
So while fully deserved, Gluttony’s fearful death retains an underlying tragedy derived from his inherent naivete. It completes his arc in a satisfying yet oddly sorrowful way.
Conclusion: A death befitting the sin
The gruesome undoing of Gluttony at the hands of Pride acts as a poetic end for the ever-hungry homunculus in Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. While disturbing, his tortuous demise completes his arc as the embodiment of gluttony – the ultimate consequences of unchecked desire taking physical form.
Brotherhood uses his death both for plot expediency and thematic resonance. Compared to his quicker 2003 anime death, Gluttony’s extended slow demise in Brotherhood better encapsulates his childish nature while bringing his indulgent sins full circle.
So for both character and plot, Gluttony’s fearful realization and ironic consumption fulfills his purpose – presenting a grim end befitting such a darkly insatiable figure. It is a harsh morality tale contained in one harrowing, hard-to-watch scene.